Everton transfer news: Toffees earmark Championship defender as Jarrad Branthwaite replacement – Whisper+ verdict

Everton target Maxime Esteve
Everton identify Esteve as Branthwaite replacement - Photo by IMAGO

Latest developments

  • Everton place Maxime Esteve on transfer shortlist.
  • Esteve is Everton's top target to replace Jarrad Branthwaite.
  • West Ham United and AC Milan are also in the mix.

Whisper+ analysis

Authenticity (3/5): Everton eyeing Esteve as Branthwaite successor

Everton have reportedly placed Burnley's Esteve on their transfer shortlist for the summer transfer window.

According to Foot Mercato, the Toffees view the 22-year-old as their priority to target to replace Branthwaite, who is being linked with a move away from the Merseyside club. The report also claims that West Ham and AC Milan have made enquiries to establish what it will take to prise him away from Turf Moor.

Value (3/5): Burnley set to demand considerable fee

While an exact number has not been mentioned, Milan's interest has seemingly cooled after they were informed of Burnley's asking price.

With that in mind, it appears the Clarets will demand a significant fee for a player who is under contract until the summer of 2029.

Suitability (4/5): Key part of best Championship defence

Esteve spent the second half of last season on loan at Burnley from Montpellier, before he completed a permanent switch last summer. The 22-year-old has established himself as a key part of the Burnley side, demonstrated by the fact he has started all 39 league matches this season.

The Frenchman has helped his team claim 28 clean sheets and establish the best defensive record in the league with just 11 goals conceded.

Upgrade? (2.5/5): Tough act to follow

Everton could make an effort to sign Esteve if Branthwaite leaves during the summer transfer window. The Burnley centre-back may have proven himself in the Championship, but Branthwaite has showcased his defensive qualities in the top flight. Everton will be looking for someone to seamlessly slot in if they need to delve into the transfer market to replace the Englishman.

Logic (3/5): Future depends on promotion

The viability of this move will surely depend on whether Burnley can secure an immediate return to the top flight. If they fail to get promoted, Esteve could look to move elsewhere to play in the Premier League or one of the top leagues in Europe.

Whisper+ verdict: 15.5/25

Scott Parker's side will be reluctant to part ways with one of their key defenders. Burnley are under no immediate pressure to sell due to the player's contract situation, but they may find it difficult to keep the centre-back if they fail to win promotion to the Premier League.