Plymouth vs Barnsley prediction, odds & betting tips 02/08/2025
🔥 Our Hot tip

Both teams to score

Both teams have scored in each of Plymouth's last five competitive matches.

Plymouth will take on Barnsley on Saturday, 2 August, as part of the opening set of League One fixtures for the season.

The hosts are back in League One following their relegation from the Championship at the end of last season, and will be desperate to secure an immediate return to the second tier.

Barnsley, meanwhile, will also be hoping to be in the promotion picture this season after a disappointing 12th-placed finish last season.

As part of our opening set of League One betting tips, check out our Plymouth vs Barnsley prediction.

Plymouth vs Barnsley prediction: A goal glut at Home Park

Key Stats

  • Both teams have scored in each of Barnsley's last ten League One matches.
  • Both teams have scored in three of Plymouth's four pre-season friendlies.
  • More than three goals have been scored in four of Barnsley's last six League One matches.

Correct score prediction: Plymouth 3-1 Barnsley

Barnsley were one of the most entertaining teams to watch at the back end of last season, but not always for the right reasons. Those final games were Conor Hourihane's first matches in management, but there is no indication that he wants to tighten things up, which should mean more open Barnsley matches to start the new season.

Pre-game odds and win probability: A tough match to call

  • HOME: 6/5 (2.20) – 45.5%
  • DRAW: 13/5 (3.60) – 27.8%
  • AWAY: 2/1 (3.00) – 33.3%

*odds from Ladbrokes, subject to change

The Plymouth vs Barnsley odds are illustrative of how closely matched these two teams are on paper. Ladbrokes have made Plymouth the narrow favourites, with home advantage being the key, giving them a 45.5% chance of victory. Meanwhile, Barnsley have been given just a 33.3% chance of walking away with all three points.

Visit our latest football tips page for more free predictions.

Most recent H2Hs: Honours even

Plymouth and Barnsley have only met on two occasions in the last five years, which makes those two fixtures the only two worth analysing. Across those two meetings in 2022 and 2023, both teams enjoyed one win each, with both of those victories going the way of the team playing at home.

England League 1 11/03/23

Barnsley

Barnsley

3
Plymouth

Plymouth

0

England League 1 30/07/22

Plymouth

Plymouth

1
Barnsley

Barnsley

0

England League 1 22/04/19

Plymouth

Plymouth

0
Barnsley

Barnsley

3

England League 1 02/10/18

Barnsley

Barnsley

1
Plymouth

Plymouth

1

Plymouth preview: Looking to bounce back

It's a fresh start for Plymouth this season in a new division, with a new manager and several new players. The departure of Ryan Hardie sparked a string of summer signings, including Aribim Pepple. The Canadian striker is expected to make his competitive debut for the club this summer and is the man being trusted to score the goals to take the club back up.

Predicted lineup: Hazard (GK), Edwards, Szucs, Wiredu, MacKenzie, Ibrahim, Boateng, Amaechi, Watts, Paterson, Pepple

England Championship 03/05/25

L

Leeds

Leeds

2

Plymouth

Plymouth

1

England Championship 26/04/25

W

Preston

Preston

1

Plymouth

Plymouth

2

England Championship 21/04/25

W

Coventry

Coventry

1

Plymouth

Plymouth

3

England Championship 18/04/25

L

Middlesbrough

Middlesbrough

2

Plymouth

Plymouth

1

England Championship 12/04/25

W

Sheff Utd

Sheff Utd

1

Plymouth

Plymouth

2

Barnsley preview: Injuries and ineligibility make things awkward

Barnsley are starting the season with several players unavailable for selection, which is hardly the ideal start. Josh Early and Marc Roberts have been ruled out with injury problems, while one of their summer signings, Nathan Ogbeta, is unavailable due to the fact he is playing against his parent club.

Predicted lineup: Smith (GK), De Gevigney, Shepherd, Barratt, Gent, Connell, Phillips, Kelly, Farrugia, Cleary, Jalo

England League 1 03/05/25

W

Reading

Reading

2

Barnsley

Barnsley

4

England League 1 26/04/25

L

Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury

2

Barnsley

Barnsley

1

England League 1 21/04/25

D

Peterborough

Peterborough

1

Barnsley

Barnsley

1

England League 1 18/04/25

L

Leyton Orient

Leyton Orient

4

Barnsley

Barnsley

3

England League 1 12/04/25

W

Bolton

Bolton

1

Barnsley

Barnsley

4

Player to watch: Aribim Pepple

Aribim Pepple
Photo by Imago

If Plymouth are to get back out of League One at the first of asking, then they are going to need someone who can score at least 15 league goals this season. Whether new signing, Aribim Pepple, is capable of that at this stage of his career remains to be seen. Pepple only managed to score five goals for Chesterfield in League Two last season, but he only joined in January.


Andy is a freelance Sports Journalist with ten years of experience covering football in the United Kingdom and abroad for various publications including the Manchester Evening News, UtdReport and Football Whispers. Andy also has a keen interest in basketball, cricket, golf and tennis and has covered major sporting events such as the Masters in Augusta.