Marcus Rashford to Everton – will it happen? Football Whispers Index scores January loan chances

Marcus Rashford to Everton – will it happen? Football Whispers Index scores January loan chances
Will Everton sign Marcus Rashford from Man United? Photo by Icon Sport/ Atilano Garcia / SOPA Images/Sipa USA/ David Klein

Everton have held early talks with Manchester United over a January move for Marcus Rashford, according to FootballTransfers.

Steve Kay broke the story on 24 October, adding that it is unclear whether Everton want a permanent deal or a loan with an option to buy.

Rashford returned to Old Trafford in the summer after scoring 14 goals and making 15 assists on loan at Barcelona, but he has no goal involvement in eight appearances and has missed United's last four games with a hip problem.

David Moyes then said on 5 November that Everton have no plans for January, although he was answering a general question about new signings and did not mention Rashford.

Marcus Rashford to Everton rated ‘Possible'

The Football Whispers Index scores every transfer rumour across five weighted factors. Read how it works here.

Football Whispers Index: Transfer predictor

Marcus Rashford to Everton

Possible
Rashford has missed four games with a hip injury and earns up to £325,000 a week, against £225,000 for Everton's highest earner Jack Grealish.
Updated
Financial viability18 / 25
Buying club need13 / 20
Player motivation4 / 15
Selling club incentive12 / 20
Market momentum10 / 20

The Football Whispers Index weighs the buyer's finances, its need for the player, the player's own motivation, the seller's incentive and the strength of the reporting.

Rashford to Everton scores 53 out of 100, which means a manageable fee and a real need at Goodison are held back by his wages, his hip injury and his reluctance to join another English club.

The talks were first reported by Steve Kay, who describes them as early with no guarantee of success, and no bid has been reported since.

Financial viability

Financial viability18 / 25
  • Barcelona decided against triggering their €30m option to sign Rashford permanently after last season's loan.
  • FootballTransfers report that Manchester United held to a €30m valuation in the summer, a fee that would equal roughly 13% of Everton's €234m annual revenue.
  • Rashford earns between £300,000 and £325,000 a week at Old Trafford, against £225,000 for Jack Grealish, Everton's highest earner.
  • His contract expires on 30 June 2028, so United would be selling with two years left to run.

The fee is the easier half of this deal, because €30m is roughly 13% of Everton's revenue and Transfermarkt rate Rashford at €35m, with FootballTransfers putting his value closer to €41.5m.

United's ask is therefore already below the data providers' estimates, which is why the summer stalemate was about wages and not about the price tag.

The wage is the real obstacle, because £300,000 to £325,000 a week sits at least £75,000 above anything Everton currently pay, with Grealish topping their scale at £225,000.

A loan with a permanent element is one of the two routes FootballTransfers say Everton are weighing, and it is the structure that would let United carry some of that cost while their leverage fades with 18 months left on his deal in January.

Buying club need

Buying club need13 / 20
  • Everton's left-wing places are held by Jack Grealish, on loan from Manchester City until June 2027, and Tyrique George.
  • Everton's move for Folarin Balogun collapsed on deadline day, leaving them short of options up front.
  • Rashford is a left winger by trade who has also played centre-forward and on the right.
  • He turns 29 on 31 October.

On the left wing, Grealish and George already give Everton cover, so Rashford would be an upgrade or a rotation option there and not the plug for an obvious hole.

The more visible gap is up front, where the Balogun pursuit fell apart on deadline day and Thierno Barry is the only recognised striker.

Rashford is only one name in that search, with Esteban Lepaul of Rennes and Dion Beljo of Dinamo Zagreb also linked with Everton and no bid reported for either.

At 29 on a salary above the club's scale, a permanent deal would be a far bigger commitment than a loan, and that tension is why the structure matters so much to the fit.

Player motivation

Player motivation4 / 15
  • FootballTransfers report that Rashford refused to consider another English club in the summer.
  • He has missed United's last four games with a hip problem, is not expected back until after the November international break and has no goal or assist in eight appearances this season.
  • Matching his current wage would make Rashford at least £75,000 a week better paid than Jack Grealish, Everton's highest earner.
  • Opta rank Manchester United 15th on 92.5 and Everton 20th on 91.8.

Rashford's own stance is the biggest unknown, because FootballTransfers report he would not consider another English club in the summer, with Barcelona his priority.

Barcelona have since passed on a permanent deal, so that position may soften, but nothing the player has said suggests it has.

He has missed United's last four games with a hip problem and is not expected back until after the international break, which leaves his role at any club uncertain.

The Opta gap between the clubs is only 0.7 points, but the drop of five places and a likely pay cut give him few reasons to push for the move.

Selling club incentive

Selling club incentive12 / 20
  • FootballTransfers report that United fully expected to sell Rashford in the summer but would not move from their €30m valuation.
  • CaughtOffside report that United are lining up a bid of €45m to €50m for Sporting winger Flavio Goncalves, 19, as a possible replacement.
  • Rashford scored 14 goals and made 15 assists in 49 games at Barcelona last season and has no goal involvement in eight games since returning to United.

TEAMtalk say United are open to selling because of the £325,000 weekly wage, and FootballTransfers say the club fully expected to sell him in the summer.

The €30m price has not moved, and that is the sticking point FootballTransfers say deterred other buyers once his salary was added.

The CaughtOffside report on Goncalves suggests United are planning for life without him, but a target is not a signing, and Chelsea are also reported to be interested.

Selling after eight games without a goal involvement would also mean cashing in at a low point, which sits awkwardly with the 14 goals and 15 assists he produced at Barcelona.

Market momentum

Market momentum10 / 20
  • Steve Kay of FootballTransfers broke the story on 24 October, reporting that Everton have already held talks with United over a January move.
  • Kay says the talks are early, with no guarantee of success, and that it is unclear whether Everton want a permanent deal or a loan with an option to buy.
  • FootballTransfers expect Rashford's time at United to end in 2027, with January the earliest possible exit.

Football365, TEAMtalk and CaughtOffside have all carried the story, and each relays FootballTransfers' reporting.

Former Everton chief executive Keith Wyness added on 28 October that the move is being talked about quite strongly, although he did not describe a confirmed approach.

Moyes' answer on 5 November was general and did not mention Rashford, so it does not rule the move out, although it offers no encouragement either.

No bid has been reported and nobody has said what structure Everton would offer, and either would be the first real sign that the deal is moving.

Marcus Rashford to Everton: Will or won't it happen?

The verdict53 / 100
Everton's interest is on the record, but a hip injury, a wage well above their scale and no reported bid keep this at Possible.
It happens if United cover part of his £300,000 to £325,000 a week in a loan with an option to buy, Rashford returns fit after the international break and he accepts a move he would not entertain in the summer.
It dies if Everton cannot stretch beyond Jack Grealish's £225,000 a week, if they land a striker elsewhere, or if Rashford again holds out for a club abroad.

Rashford to Everton is a plausible fit that rests on three things the reporting has not yet settled, which are the wage, his fitness and the player's willingness.

If United pay part of the salary through a loan with an option, Rashford returns fit after the international break and he is open to staying in England, the deal becomes workable by January.

If Everton cannot stretch beyond Grealish's £225,000, land a striker elsewhere or Rashford holds out for a move abroad, it ends before a bid is made.


Byron is a sports journalist based in South Africa. He has a Media degree from the University of Kwa Zulu Natal and has been writing football content since 2019. Byron is also a sports presenter with experience in radio particularly.