Latest developments
- Newcastle United have been monitoring Crystal Palace defender Marc Guehi.
- But Sven Botman's return to fitness may impact their intention to bid.
- The England international's contract runs down in the summer of 2026.
Whisper+ analysis
Authenticity (3.5/5): The Times sources are trustworthy
Marc Guehi has been on Newcastle United's transfer shortlist for a while, with the Palace defender attracting interest from many wealthy clubs.
However, according to The Times, Newcastle may not put in a January bid thanks to Sven Botman's return to fitness. The source is unclear, but the newspaper can usually be trusted.
Value (3.5/5): Price rising despite Palace's struggles
On Transfermarkt, Guehi's valuation has had one of its sharpest rises this season, from €38 million to €45 million, despite the Eagles having a dreadful start to Oliver Glasner's first full season in charge.
In the summer, the Magpies had three bids rejected for Guehi, with one reportedly in the region of £55 million. Now, with Palace struggling, Newcastle will have to offer significantly more for the Londoners to agree.
Suitability (5/5): No doubting his quality
Guehi's value increase despite Palace sitting in the relegation zone is testament to his quality as a Premier League defender. The back four that Eddie Howe plays will offer a seamless transition, and Guehi's England experience suggests he can handle the pressure of playing at St James' Park.
Upgrade? (4/5): Magpies have solid options
Sven Botman's expected return from injury next month casting doubt on a potential bid suggests Newcastle are content with their centre-back options, which include Dan Burn, Fabian Schar and Lloyd Kelly.
Guehi will be an upgrade on those players in most fans' eyes, but his price tag is making Newcastle stick with what they've got.
Logic (4/5): Guehi too good for relegation battle
The loss of Michael Olise and the loss of form of Jean-Philippe Mateta have hit Crystal Palace hard, and unless they can do some great January business, they will be in a relegation dogfight this season.
Guehi is far too good to be languishing in the Premier League basement, and though his departure could be the final nail in the Palace coffin, it would be smart for him to move on before it's too late.
Whisper+ verdict: 20/25
It would be an expensive purchase, but our verdict is that Newcastle should stay in the hunt to bring Marc Guehi to Tyneside. They will be getting one of the best centre-backs in the country, whose desire to stay at Palace will be significantly lower compared to the summer.
