New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew prediction, odds & betting tips – 10/20/2024
Photo by IMAGO
🔥 Our Hot tip

Draw or Columbus Crew

The Crew won three of the last five head-to-heads.

Red Bull Arena will host the New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew head-to-head on the 20th of October. The Bulls have the home-field advantage, but we should still pay respect to the Crew, as they are the current MLS Champions. Check out the following New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew betting tips to find out more about this match.

If you want more expert MLS predictions, check our designated page.

New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew prediction: The Crew will do it again

Key Stats

  • Cucho Hernandez is the leading goalscorer for his team, with 19 goals since the start of the season.
  • Columbus Crew’s last loss against the Bulls was almost a year ago.
  • Hernandez was the top goalscorer for his team last season as well.

Correct score prediction: New York Red Bulls 1-2 Columbus Crew

You might want to find out that the most common result we’ve seen from this rivalry throughout the past few years is the 2-1 Columbus Crew win. Therefore, we have high confidence that our professional New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew predictions will succeed.

Pre-game odds and win probability: Bulls will surprise us, bookies claim

  • HOME: +137 – 41.1%
  • DRAW: +240 – 23.0%
  • AWAY: +170 – 35.9%

*These New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew odds are subject to change

We believe fans at Red Bull Arena will surely see Cucho Hernandez to score anytime become a reality, as the odds behind our key New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew prediction are valued at +149, giving it a 40.16% success chance.

What’s surprising is that New York Red Bulls are considered by the experts as the expected winners before the kick-off, with a 41.1% win probability behind them.

Last five H2Hs: Advantage goes to the champions

In the charts below, we have some interesting New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew statistics to share with you.

USA MLS 16/03/24

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

3
New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

0

USA MLS 02/07/23

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2
New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

1

USA MLS 18/03/23

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

2
Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1

USA MLS 02/10/22

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2
New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

1

USA MLS 20/03/22

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

1
Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1

New York Red Bulls team news and form: Forsberg out

New York Red Bulls are going to have to throw everything they’ve got at the Crew if they want to get the three points here. After all, the Bulls’ manager won’t be able to count on team captain Emil Forsberg who is still injured.

Predicted lineup: Coronel (GK), Eile, Nealis, Reyes, Harper, Donkor, Edelman, Carballo, Tolkin, Morgan & Vanzeir

USA MLS 12/04/25

D

Orlando City SC

Orlando City SC

0

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

0

USA MLS 05/04/25

W

Chicago Fire

Chicago Fire

1

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

2

USA MLS 29/03/25

L

New England Revolution

New England Revolution

2

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

1

USA MLS 22/03/25

W

Toronto FC

Toronto FC

1

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

2

USA MLS 15/03/25

D

Orlando City SC

Orlando City SC

2

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

2

Columbus Crew team news and form: Champions to end second

Despite giving their best, Columbus Crew weren’t able to beat high-flying Herons for 1st place in MLS’ Eastern Conference. However, coach Wilfried Nancy’s boys still did very well, as securing a second spot is not an easy task to accomplish.

Predicted lineup: Romero (GK), Camacho, Amundsen, Cheberko, Chambost, Jones, Nagbe, Arfsen, Matan, Hernandez & Jackson

USA MLS 13/04/25

W

St. Louis City SC

St. Louis City SC

1

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2

USA MLS 05/04/25

W

CF Montreal

CF Montreal

1

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2

USA MLS 29/03/25

D

DC United

DC United

1

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1

USA MLS 22/03/25

D

New York City FC

New York City FC

0

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

0

USA MLS 16/03/25

D

San Diego FC

San Diego FC

1

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1

Player to watch: Cucho Hernandez

As stated previously in our top New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew prediction, Hernandez is the leading finisher for the visitors. He slid it past the shot-stoppers on 19 occasions and managed to provide teammates with nine assists.

New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew prediction 2
Photo by IMAGO

Second player to watch: Alexandru Matan

25-year-old attacking midfielder Alexandru Matan was a force of nature in the game against New England Revolution. Coach Caleb Porter’s boys were shell-shocked by his tremendous goalscoring capabilities at Mercedes-Benz Stadium, as he scored a hattrick for his manager.


Zack is a longtime football fan, writer, and bettor. He also has experience playing and coaching the game of football at a local level. His interest in the MLS, Liga MX and the Canadian Premier League adds a new dimension to the content we have at FootballWhispers.