Columbus Crew vs New York City prediction, odds & betting tips – 09/01/2024

Columbus Crew vs New York City Prediction 1
The two teams are going at at again. - Photo by IMAGO
🔥 Our Hot tip

New York City under 1.5 total goals

The Crew have the best defensive record in the Eastern Conference, with 22 goals conceded.

The Crew are taking on New York City at Lower.com Field on the 1st day of September and we can’t wait for the kick-off! This Eastern Conference showdown will undoubtedly be very interesting, as both teams are currently playing at their lethal best. Find out more about it in the following Columbus Crew vs New York City betting tips below.

If you want more expert MLS predictions, check our designated page.

Columbus Crew vs New York City prediction: The Crew to achieve what’s expected of them

Key Stats

  • Columbus Crew have the 2nd-best attacking record in the Eastern Conference, with 47 goals bagged since the start of the season.
  • The Crew won 12 of their 23 Major League Soccer matches this season.
  • Coach Nick Cushing has a horrible 0-2-3 record against this opponent.

Correct score prediction: Columbus Crew 2-1 New York City

We believe our key Columbus Crew vs New York City predictions may succeed, as two of the last nine games between the two teams had 2-1 in favor of the 2023 MLS Champions on the scoreboard after 90 minutes of soccer.

Pre-game odds and win probability: The Crew can maintain a steady course of winning

  • HOME: -133 – 55.9%
  • DRAW: +310 – 23.2%
  • AWAY: +350 – 21.0%

*These Columbus Crew vs New York City odds are subject to change

Over 1.5 Columbus Crew goals is priced at +118, giving our top Columbus Crew vs New York City prediction a decent enough 46.51% success chance.

Coach Nancy’s players are also considered by the bookmakers as the expected winners. Columbus Crew have a massive 55.9% win probability behind them at -133, which is almost three times higher than the visitors’ 21.0% shot at the three points.

Last five H2Hs: Two-year winless spell for the visitors

If you are wondering just how poorly the visitors have been performing recently, check out these interesting Columbus Crew vs New York City statistics.

Leagues Cup 17/08/24

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1 (4)
New York City FC

New York City FC

1 (3)

USA MLS 15/06/24

New York City FC

New York City FC

2
Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

3

USA MLS 09/07/23

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1
New York City FC

New York City FC

1

USA MLS 17/06/23

New York City FC

New York City FC

1
Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1

USA MLS 07/08/22

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

3
New York City FC

New York City FC

2

Columbus Crew team news and form: Leagues Cup fever still here

After beating coach Steven Cherundolo’s LAFC in the grand final, the Crew managed to pick up the Leagues Cup title. Surely, the fans are on cloud nine over this unexpected success. However, the players’ focus must be on the match against New York City, as the visitors are no joke.

Predicted lineup: Hagen (GK), Moreira, Camacho, Amundsen, Nagbe, Arfsten, Zawadzki, Rossi, Farsi, Ramirez & Hernandez

USA MLS 02/10/24

L

Inter Miami CF

Inter Miami CF

3

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2

USA MLS 28/09/24

D

DC United

DC United

2

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2

Campeones Cup 25/09/24

D

Club America

Club America

1

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

1

USA MLS 21/09/24

W

Orlando City SC

Orlando City SC

3

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

4

USA MLS 18/09/24

W

Toronto FC

Toronto FC

0

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

2

New York City team news and form: Expected hero for New York City

In last week’s 2-2 fiasco versus Chicago Fire, we saw Alonso Martinez scoring a brace. The two goals at home bumped his tally up to 10 goals. Surely, he will be a starter for his manager this week and, of course, he will do everything within his power to disprove our key Columbus Crew vs New York City predictions.

Predicted lineup: Freese (GK), Risa, Martins, Gray, McFarlane, Parks, Sands, Wolf, Moralez, Rodriguez & Martinez

USA MLS 02/10/24

W

FC Cincinnati

FC Cincinnati

2

New York City FC

New York City FC

3

USA MLS 28/09/24

W

New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

1

New York City FC

New York City FC

5

USA MLS 21/09/24

D

Inter Miami CF

Inter Miami CF

1

New York City FC

New York City FC

1

USA MLS 18/09/24

L

Philadelphia Union

Philadelphia Union

5

New York City FC

New York City FC

1

USA MLS 14/09/24

D

DC United

DC United

1

New York City FC

New York City FC

1

Player to watch: Cucho Hernandez

Back when the Crew signed Hernandez, the fans expressed concerns he wouldn’t fit in. Well, the Colombian goalscoring machine comes into the match with two goals in the Leagues Cup final against LAFC. Goals which were vital for the final 3-1 score at Lower.com Field.

Columbus Crew vs New York City Prediction 2
Cucho Hernandez can ruin New York City's plans. – Photo by IMAGO

Second player to watch: Diego Rossi

Behind every tremendous goalscorer is a talented creator. Such is the case here as well, as Rossi is the top assists-provider for the home team.


Zack is a longtime football fan, writer, and bettor. He also has experience playing and coaching the game of football at a local level. His interest in the MLS, Liga MX and the Canadian Premier League adds a new dimension to the content we have at FootballWhispers.